Years ago, Facebook ad targeting meant a tool called Power Editor. That tool is long retired — everything now lives in Meta Ads Manager — but the idea behind it is more powerful than ever: instead of bidding at strangers, you aim your ads at people who already know you, and at people who look just like them. Here's the current playbook.
Custom audiences: target people who already know you
- Customer lists: upload emails or phone numbers of customers who opted in — Meta matches them to accounts. CSV exports from your email platform work fine.
- Website visitors: with your Meta pixel installed, you can retarget anyone who visited, or just the ones who hit pricing and left.
- Engagers: people who interacted with your page, posts or videos — warm, cheap, and easy to convert.
Lookalike audiences: find everyone who looks like them
Take your best custom audience — buyers, not just subscribers — and let Meta find people who share their traits. Lookalikes are how a small customer list becomes a full funnel: the closer the source list is to your ideal customer, the better the match.
Use Audience Insights to sharpen the picture
Meta's Audience Insights shows the demographics and interests of the audience you've built — age ranges, locations, the pages they like. Use it to refine your creative and targeting, and to spot adjacencies worth testing.
Planning beats improvising
None of this works without a plan. A workable social media plan in six steps: set one measurable goal per campaign; know exactly who you're targeting (build 1-3 audience personas and define them by demographics, interests and pain points); pick the platforms where those people actually are; plan the content mix — useful, human, and occasionally promotional; decide the budget and the measurement; then review monthly and reallocate toward what worked.
Bottom line: the tools changed their names but the advantage is the same — advertise to people who know you, and to people who look exactly like them. Build the list, install the pixel, plan the calendar. If you'd rather have it run for you, our Facebook & Instagram Ads service is that job.
Written by Todd Meisler · 2026-10-20
Want this applied to your business?
Book a free 30-minute call with Todd — a plain-language read on your website, SEO and advertising.
